I love ESPN Classic. Especially during baseball season when they'll just show a random game like a 1993 September contest between Atlanta and Cincinnati. Chris Berman, Buck Martinez and Peter Gammons are the commentators and the Braves are in contention while the Reds are clearly looking toward the future. The camera pans over to the Reds dugout where we see Tim Costo. Gammons has plenty to say about the 24-year old outfielder/corner infielder including this gem, "Davey Johnson believes he can hit 25-30 home runs in the future." Let's take a look at Costo's career numbers:
YR AB HR RBI OPS
1992 36 0 2 .588
1993 98 3 12 .617
That's it! Not only did he not go onto to hit 25-30 home runs, he never played another season. If this isn't proof that the game of forecasting baseball prospects is extremely hit-or-miss, then I don't know what is. The Cleveland Indians selected Costo 8th overall in 1990, so there was obviously some promise. He was traded to the Reds for Reggie Jefferson in 1991 and then back to the Indians in 1994 for Mark Lewis. He would never suit up for the Indians on a Major League level.
Surely many baseball fans can name good handful of "can't-miss" prospects that missed. Kevin Maas, Todd Van Poppel, Nigel Wilson and David Nied are among some of the most popular. While Maas had two 20+ HR seasons, Van Poppel was nearly as wretched in the minors as he was in the majors and both Wilson and Nied, the first picks of expansion teams Florida and Colorado respectively, were complete busts.
Being a baseball scout is like being a meteorologist, you can mess up more than half the time and still hold your job. A quick glance of the top 10 picks of any baseball draft will bring as much laughter as surprise. The job saving comes in the fact that for every Bill Haselman, who was picked in the first round by Texas in 1987 and has amassed 47 career home runs in 13 years, there's a Carlos Delgado, who was signed as an Amateur Free Agent in 1988.
There is no exact science to it, but despite many fans knowing that, they expect only the best from their teams and GMs. Luckily for GMs, many fans tend to forget the blown picks after a few years. After all, how many Met fans remember 1993 when their team selected high school pitcher Kirk Presley from Tupelo, MS? Though this isn't always true because as a Tigers fan, I can't seem to forget the 1997 #1 overall selection of Matt Anderson. No Vernon Wells, no Troy Glaus, or Lance Berkman, Randy Wolf (2nd RD) or Tim Hudson (6th RD), but Matt Anderson. The Rice closer further proved why you shouldn't take college closers in the first round of the draft. His career ERA is 6 seasons sits at a bulky 4.89 and the team has tried out several closers since before finally settling with Ugueth Urbina, an early season free agent signee from the Champion Florida Marlins.
Truthfully, I'm not bitter. Baseball and it's interminable draft (50 Rounds!) is sure to produce a series of busts and steals year in and year out. I just wonder what guys like Antone Williamson (#4 pick in '94) or Brien Taylor (#1 in '91) think now. They had it made when the Brewers and Yankees took them that high, but together the two played 24 major league games (all by Williamson). Sure Tim Costo's life may not be completely worthless, but if he is at home watching the same ESPN Classic game I am, he has to wonder what could've been had he made good on the promise that scouts and managers saw to dub him a potential 25-30 home run player.